Solid media · Technical article and analysis

1. Reversible cycles with a solid thermodynamic medium

Define a closed solid cycle and explore the aluminium Carnot reference, matched T–Q trajectories and finite temperature differences at both heat contacts.

Define the solid, its state and its heat contacts

Classical thermodynamics commonly illustrates cycles using gases and phase-changing fluids. The same principles apply to deformable solids that undergo cyclic changes of state and exchange heat and mechanical work. Through thermoelastic coupling, elastic loading or unloading can change the solid’s temperature even during a thermally isolated process. The sign and magnitude depend on the material, loading mode and initial state.

Start by specifying the boundary of the solid medium M and a conjugate mechanical pair, such as force and displacement or, in a small-strain uniaxial model, stress and strain. The complete state must repeat after one cycle, including temperature, the relevant deformation or stress, and any phase or internal variables. In a spatially nonuniform body this includes the full temperature field.

In the heat-engine direction, the solid absorbs heat at the warm contact, rejects heat at the cold contact and delivers net work. Reversing the complete reversible path gives heat-pump operation. An insulated loading and unloading excursion retraced reversibly can close, with zero heat exchange and zero net work. A heat–work cycle requires specified thermal contacts and a mechanically admissible path back to the initial state.

Reversibility, mechanical work and material loss

A cycle is thermodynamically reversible if it can be reversed while restoring both the system and its surroundings to their initial states, without a lasting change. For the coupled solid-cycle reference, mechanical loading and unloading, any phase change and the connecting processes must be reversible. At each active thermal contact, corresponding local temperatures must match in the reversible limit.

In a cyclic material test, internal mechanical damping can appear as a hysteretic difference between loading and unloading paths. In an operating heat–work cycle, the full force–displacement loop represents net mechanical work delivered or supplied. Its area alone does not identify a material loss: a reversible heat–work cycle can enclose a work-producing or work-consuming loop.

The reversible reference excludes internal mechanical dissipation, dissipative material hysteresis, friction and intrinsic relaxation losses. Any benchmark-relative lost work must identify a reversible counterpart with declared common constraints and reference conditions.

Energy and Clausius balances

ΔUM,cycle = 0 Wout = Qin − Qout ∮ δQM/TM = 0 (internally reversible M)

Heat into M is positive in the Clausius integral, Qin and Qout denote positive magnitudes, and Wout is positive for work delivered. The first two relations follow from full state closure and the first law. The third requires internal reversibility and uses the absolute temperature at the medium side of each active heat-transfer boundary. Reversibility of the coupled operation also requires reversible thermal contacts and mechanical interactions. For two internally reversible isothermal branches, Qin/Tin = Qout/Tout, with Tin and Tout the temperatures of the respective heat interactions on the medium side. Gliding interactions require integration over their full trajectories.

Locate the irreversibility before interpreting damping

Nonuniform elastic deformation can make neighbouring regions of a solid warmer and colder. Heat conduction across the resulting internal temperature differences generates entropy and, under cyclic loading, can contribute to thermoelastic damping. This is the sole internal damping route retained in the restricted thermoelastic interpretation discussed here; real solids can also have other dissipative mechanisms within their elastic loading range.

The small, spatially temperature-uniform medium assumed in the contact T–Q diagrams has no internal temperature gradients. The irreversibility depicted there resides in heat exchange between that medium and its neighbouring bodies. An internally reversible medium can complete its own state cycle while those external contacts make the coupled operation irreversible. External contact irreversibility is not by itself intrinsic mechanical damping of the medium.

The later finite-reservoir and material-response chapters calculate the coupled thermal and mechanical evolution for their specified model. Read their work and entropy balances together when interpreting a mechanical response as damping.

Aluminium Carnot reference

Explore the idealised aluminium Carnot reference. The solid returns to its starting state after two isothermal and two isentropic processes. Both external contact temperatures match the corresponding solid temperatures in the reversible limit.

Closed stress–strain trajectory · Stress (MPa)
47.009457.850268.69179.531890.3727733.199869.7461,006.291,142.841,279.39Engineering strain (µε)
1 → 2 isothermal loading2 → 3 adiabatic loading3 → 4 isothermal unloading4 → 1 adiabatic unloading

Energy exchanged per cycle

High-temperature heat 50.00000 J/kg · Low-temperature heat 49.99167 J/kg.

Net work delivered 0.00833 J/kg.

Thermal efficiency 0.01666%.

The loop integral gives the net mechanical work with the chosen sign convention. This reference uses a reversible constitutive model and excludes intrinsic material losses.

From locally matched to mismatched T–Q trajectories

For each contact, compare the temperatures of the medium and its neighbour at the same transferred-heat increment. Reversible exchange requires local equality over the full duty. The two temperatures can glide together as heat is transferred. The T–Q trajectories describe the thermal interaction. The solid’s mechanical path follows from the constitutive model and the imposed process conditions.

In the illustrated heat-pump direction, loading can warm the solid as it rejects heat to a warmer-side neighbour, and unloading can cool it as it absorbs heat from a colder-side neighbour. At the active high contact the medium is hotter than its neighbour. At the low contact the medium is cooler. In heat-engine operation both heat-flow directions reverse. The medium can be approximately uniform in space at each instant while its temperature changes over time. A single neighbouring body can act as source and sink at different times. In that case its state must be tracked through both contacts. An engine cannot deliver net work in a closed cycle by exchanging heat solely with one isothermal body.

Loading and heat rejection, illustrative temperature versus transferred heatThe medium and adjacent high-temperature body meet at the left endpoint. Over positive transferred heat the medium is hotter than the adjacent body.TQMedium MAdjacent body RH
Loading · heat rejectedTM(Q) > TR,H(Q) after the initial contact point.
Unloading and heat absorption, illustrative temperature versus transferred heatThe medium and adjacent low-temperature body meet at the left endpoint. Over positive transferred heat the adjacent body is hotter than the medium.TQAdjacent body RCMedium M
Unloading · heat absorbedTR,C(Q) > TM(Q) after the initial contact point.

Schematic T–Q paths in the heat-pump direction. Q increases with the magnitude of heat transferred in each panel and resets to zero between panels. The lines meet at the starting point and diverge over the remaining duty. The profiles illustrate prescribed trajectories. A complete cycle also requires compatible mechanical processes and state closure.

Finite differences under prescribed process constraints

For an increment δq flowing from the hotter to the colder side, the contact contribution is δq(1/Tcold − 1/Thot), using absolute temperatures. Take the two exchanging bodies together, idealize each side as internally reversible over the increment and exclude heat leaks. The positive contribution has units J/K for δq in joules. Integrate over each duty, then sum both contacts under the same boundary and sign convention. It vanishes for locally matched reversible contacts and is positive for heat transfer across a finite temperature difference. At a point of exact temperature matching, finite conductance gives zero instantaneous heat flux. A larger conductance reduces the difference needed for a given flux. Independently prescribed incompatible T–Q paths still require a coupled calculation of their temperatures, conductance and transfer rates.

If the regions form one continuous solid with ideal thermal contact, temperature can be continuous at their shared boundary. The finite temperature difference then lies along a conducting path between locations, rather than as a jump at the boundary. Specify the locations and thermal path before assigning paired T–Q temperatures.

The contact balance applies established Clausius-entropy principles to the stated solid-medium/adjacent-body model. The gliding T–Q panels are schematic interpretations, not measured material behaviour. The aluminium and elastocaloric examples are bounded educational models and do not establish a general material-damping law.

Irreversible heat exchange at one or both contacts

Use the same solid cycle and heat quantities. Set a finite temperature difference at either contact or at both. The controls move the reservoir temperatures in the direction required for the selected operation. A zero setting denotes the ideal reversible contact limit. The two contacts can be varied independently while retaining the same working-medium path.

High contact: reservoir to solid · Temperature relative to solid isotherm (mK)
-0.08-0.0400.040.08012.52537.550Transferred heat (J/kg)
Solid working mediumExternal reservoir
Low contact: solid to reservoir · Temperature relative to solid isotherm (mK)
-0.08-0.0400.040.08012.497924.995837.493849.9917Transferred heat (J/kg)
Solid working mediumExternal reservoir

Contact entropy generation Σ = Q(1/Treceiver − 1/Tsource), using absolute temperatures in kelvin.

High contact (J/kg·K)
0.000e+0
Low contact (J/kg·K)
0.000e+0
Both contacts (J/kg·K)
0.000e+0

This comparison holds the solid trajectory and heat duties fixed to isolate contact irreversibility. The finite-reservoir chapter calculates how the solid and its neighbour change temperature together over time.